navigation
  • Toys & Hobbies
  • Stuffed Animals
  • + 30 subcategories
  • Handmade
  • Animal Alley
  • Applause
  • Aurora
  • Coca-Cola
  • Dakin
  • Dan Dee
  • Disney
  • Eden
  • FAO Schwarz
  • First & Main
  • Fisher Price
  • Gund
  • Hansa
  • Jellycat
  • Kookeys
  • Limited Treasures
  • Melissa & Doug
  • Neopets
  • Pound Puppies
  • Princess Soft Toys
  • Puffkins
  • Russ
  • Steiff
  • Uglydolls
  • Warner Bros.
  • Webkinz & Lil'Kinz
  • Vintage
  • Mixed Lots
  • Other Stuffed Animals
Vintage Steiff Tulla Duck Swimming  3205/15 with Button Tag $4.00

Vintage Steiff Tulla Duck Swimming 3205/15 with Button Tag

0 bids

GANZ HM375 Stuffed Webkinz MOOSE Plush BROWN/BLACK WITH TAG/CODE $12.99

GANZ HM375 Stuffed Webkinz MOOSE Plush BROWN/BLACK WITH TAG/CODE

0 bids

Hugfun Int'l Cinnamon Dog Blue Brown Hat Scarf Plush Stuffed Animal $20.00

Hugfun Int'l Cinnamon Dog Blue Brown Hat Scarf Plush Stuffed Animal

0 bids

 Purr-Fection by MJC Realistic 1992 Standing Plush/Stuffed Animal Giraffe 11"  $7.99

Purr-Fection by MJC Realistic 1992 Standing Plush/Stuffed Animal Giraffe 11"

0 bids

Russ Berrie Luv U Latte Stuffed Latte $19.98

Russ Berrie Luv U Latte Stuffed Latte

0 bids

Walgreens Squishmallows Easter 2021 Belana the Blue Cow with bandana 16" NWT $54.99

Walgreens Squishmallows Easter 2021 Belana the Blue Cow with bandana 16" NWT

0 bids

Little Buddy Super Mario Series Lemmy Koopa 8" Plush $19.78

Little Buddy Super Mario Series Lemmy Koopa 8" Plush

0 bids

Chewbacca Squishmallow 20” BRAND NEW $70.00

Chewbacca Squishmallow 20” BRAND NEW

0 bids

Kellytoy 26" Large Plush Long Arm Penguin Fuzzy Stuffed Animal Vintage Rare $25.00

Kellytoy 26" Large Plush Long Arm Penguin Fuzzy Stuffed Animal Vintage Rare

0 bids

Cate & Levi - Hand Puppet - Premium Reclaimed Wool - Handmade in Canada - Machin $30.66

Cate & Levi - Hand Puppet - Premium Reclaimed Wool - Handmade in Canada - Machin

0 bids

 Classic Collection | Frog and Toad Plush Friends $74.34

Classic Collection | Frog and Toad Plush Friends

0 bids

TILLYOU Soft Baby Rattle for Newborns, Plush Stuffed Animal Rattle, Rattle for & $11.68

TILLYOU Soft Baby Rattle for Newborns, Plush Stuffed Animal Rattle, Rattle for &

0 bids

VINTAGE 1990 GUND LIGHT GREEN FROG W/ RATTLE 9" Plush STUFFED ANIMAL TOY $19.99

VINTAGE 1990 GUND LIGHT GREEN FROG W/ RATTLE 9" Plush STUFFED ANIMAL TOY

0 bids

Aurora Miyoni Lioness Plush RARE Laying Baby Lion Cat Stuffed Animal TAGS 12" $39.00

Aurora Miyoni Lioness Plush RARE Laying Baby Lion Cat Stuffed Animal TAGS 12"

0 bids

Adorable Yellow Orange Stars Geoffrey Giraffe Plush Stuffie Toys R Us 2017 17" $24.95

Adorable Yellow Orange Stars Geoffrey Giraffe Plush Stuffie Toys R Us 2017 17"

0 bids

2016 Animal Adventure: Cream Teddy Bear 13" Plush $10.00

2016 Animal Adventure: Cream Teddy Bear 13" Plush

0 bids

Galerie Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Teddy Bear Plush 7” Tall  Attached To Heart $1.99

Galerie Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Teddy Bear Plush 7” Tall Attached To Heart

0 bids

Disney Squishmallows 20in Mickey Mouse Plush Ultra-Soft Kellytoy Pillow Squish $69.88

Disney Squishmallows 20in Mickey Mouse Plush Ultra-Soft Kellytoy Pillow Squish

0 bids

Brand New! NWT 11” Squishmallow Chelsea Cheetah by Kellytoy $14.00

Brand New! NWT 11” Squishmallow Chelsea Cheetah by Kellytoy

0 bids

Lion King Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Nuzzling Simba & Nala 10" New! Excellent $19.99

Lion King Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Nuzzling Simba & Nala 10" New! Excellent

0 bids

Build-A-Bear Carnival Cruise Line St. Jude Care To Play Plush Teddy Bear $10.00

Build-A-Bear Carnival Cruise Line St. Jude Care To Play Plush Teddy Bear

0 bids

Ikea Orange Carrot Green Broccoli Plush Soft Pillow Veggie People Large 25” $24.99

Ikea Orange Carrot Green Broccoli Plush Soft Pillow Veggie People Large 25”

0 bids

IKEA Torva Broccoli Veggie Pillow Vegetable Plush Soft Stuffed Toy 23" EUC $19.99

IKEA Torva Broccoli Veggie Pillow Vegetable Plush Soft Stuffed Toy 23" EUC

0 bids

2 Victoria Secret Plush Dogs Polka Dot Pink & White, Purple & Black $10.99

2 Victoria Secret Plush Dogs Polka Dot Pink & White, Purple & Black

0 bids

Cute Starred Pink Unicorn Plush $24.00

Cute Starred Pink Unicorn Plush

0 bids

Vintage Monkey Toy Animated $20.00

Vintage Monkey Toy Animated

0 bids

6.5" Vintage R Dakin 1979 Elephant Plush LT gray Ears Rare plush Stuffed Animal $20.00

6.5" Vintage R Dakin 1979 Elephant Plush LT gray Ears Rare plush Stuffed Animal

0 bids

CHRISTMAS TIME SNOWMAN BLACK HAT MINI 4” PLUSH! $4.95

CHRISTMAS TIME SNOWMAN BLACK HAT MINI 4” PLUSH!

0 bids

2019 Dr. Dolittle 8" Plush Themed Toy White Polar Bear Yoshi Universal Studios $23.00

2019 Dr. Dolittle 8" Plush Themed Toy White Polar Bear Yoshi Universal Studios

0 bids

Squishmallow Clip On Todd The Cheicken 3.5” $7.00

Squishmallow Clip On Todd The Cheicken 3.5”

0 bids

CHRISTMAS PENGUIN SANTA HAT SCARF RATTLE MINI 4” PLUSH! $4.95

CHRISTMAS PENGUIN SANTA HAT SCARF RATTLE MINI 4” PLUSH!

0 bids

Squishmallow Hug Mee Talia the Tie Dye Easter Bunny Plush 14" $38.98

Squishmallow Hug Mee Talia the Tie Dye Easter Bunny Plush 14"

0 bids

Jellycat Lion Cordy Roy Ribbed Corduroy Plush Stuffed Animal 10" $19.90

Jellycat Lion Cordy Roy Ribbed Corduroy Plush Stuffed Animal 10"

0 bids

NWT NEW Squishmallow 15 Inch Easter Flattie Tie Dye Gwen Unicorn 2021 HTF $32.99

NWT NEW Squishmallow 15 Inch Easter Flattie Tie Dye Gwen Unicorn 2021 HTF

0 bids

WILD REPUBLIC ELEPHANT 13" PLUSH REALISTIC WWF WILDLIFE STUFFED ANIMAL TOY GREY $12.43

WILD REPUBLIC ELEPHANT 13" PLUSH REALISTIC WWF WILDLIFE STUFFED ANIMAL TOY GREY

0 bids

KOHL'S CARES LION PLUSH 11" TALL CARNIVORES STUFFED ANIMAL WILDLIFE TOY $9.93

KOHL'S CARES LION PLUSH 11" TALL CARNIVORES STUFFED ANIMAL WILDLIFE TOY

0 bids

FAO SCHWARZ TOYS R US WHITE WEDDING GOWN DRESS TULLE SEQUINS TEDDY BEAR DOLL $24.92

FAO SCHWARZ TOYS R US WHITE WEDDING GOWN DRESS TULLE SEQUINS TEDDY BEAR DOLL

0 bids

WILD REPUBLIC PINK SPOTTED SEAL PUP SEALIFE 16" LONG WITH TAGS PLUSH STUFFED TOY $9.93

WILD REPUBLIC PINK SPOTTED SEAL PUP SEALIFE 16" LONG WITH TAGS PLUSH STUFFED TOY

0 bids

Ganz Toffee Easter Bunny Rabbit With Carrot Fluffy Brown Rabbit 10" Pet Bunny $14.99

Ganz Toffee Easter Bunny Rabbit With Carrot Fluffy Brown Rabbit 10" Pet Bunny

0 bids

Marvel Plush Spiderman Bear $16.50

Marvel Plush Spiderman Bear

0 bids

🍊 Vintage Lisa Frank Max Splash Bean Bag Plush Whale Beanie Baby 8” RARE E9 $49.99

🍊 Vintage Lisa Frank Max Splash Bean Bag Plush Whale Beanie Baby 8” RARE E9

0 bids

VINTAGE COTC KOREA COAST ORIENT TRADING TEDDY BEAR 9” STUFFED ANIMAL PLUSH TOY $19.99

VINTAGE COTC KOREA COAST ORIENT TRADING TEDDY BEAR 9” STUFFED ANIMAL PLUSH TOY

0 bids

AURORA Set of 5 Bush Baby Boy Plush Sound Big Eye Soccer Pirate YooHoo & Friends $24.97

AURORA Set of 5 Bush Baby Boy Plush Sound Big Eye Soccer Pirate YooHoo & Friends

0 bids

Vintage 1983 Dakin Bunny Rabbit Plush Realistic Stuffed Animal Brown 10" Easter $35.86

Vintage 1983 Dakin Bunny Rabbit Plush Realistic Stuffed Animal Brown 10" Easter

0 bids

Peeps Orange Marshmallow Chick Peep Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Large 8” $21.52

Peeps Orange Marshmallow Chick Peep Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Large 8”

0 bids

JELLYCAT London Aqua Blue Bashful Bunny Rabbit Plush 12" Stuffed Animal Easter $20.31

JELLYCAT London Aqua Blue Bashful Bunny Rabbit Plush 12" Stuffed Animal Easter

0 bids

5 Animal Adventure Bunny Rabbit Plush Easter Pink Blue Gray Purple Ivory 8” NWT $30.13

5 Animal Adventure Bunny Rabbit Plush Easter Pink Blue Gray Purple Ivory 8” NWT

0 bids

Stitch Squishmallow 10” NWT! $40.00

Stitch Squishmallow 10” NWT!

0 bids

RARE Squishmallow 2021 12 Inch RONNIE The COW EASTER $30.00

RARE Squishmallow 2021 12 Inch RONNIE The COW EASTER

1 bids

Dancing Cactus Plush Toy Electronic Shake Spin Cute Dance Doll kids Toys Gift $18.99

Dancing Cactus Plush Toy Electronic Shake Spin Cute Dance Doll kids Toys Gift

0 bids

Dancing Cactus Plush Toy Electronic Shake Spin Cute Dance Doll kids Toys Gift $18.99

Dancing Cactus Plush Toy Electronic Shake Spin Cute Dance Doll kids Toys Gift

0 bids

Dancing Cactus Plush Toy Electronic Shake Spin Cute Dance Doll kids Toys Gift $17.99

Dancing Cactus Plush Toy Electronic Shake Spin Cute Dance Doll kids Toys Gift

0 bids

Dancing Cactus Plush Toy Electronic Shake Spin Cute Dance Doll kids Toys Gift $17.98

Dancing Cactus Plush Toy Electronic Shake Spin Cute Dance Doll kids Toys Gift

0 bids

Dancing Cactus Plush Toy Electronic Shake Spin Cute Dance Doll kids Toys Gift $17.99

Dancing Cactus Plush Toy Electronic Shake Spin Cute Dance Doll kids Toys Gift

0 bids

NWT Squishmallow Bunny LJ Flattie 15"  Plush*Easter 2021* New Release * $32.99

NWT Squishmallow Bunny LJ Flattie 15" Plush*Easter 2021* New Release *

0 bids

NEW 16" LARGE Gwen the Unicorn Easter 2021 Target Plush Squishmallows Kelly Toy $45.00

NEW 16" LARGE Gwen the Unicorn Easter 2021 Target Plush Squishmallows Kelly Toy

0 bids

NEW Schylling Purple Sock Monkey Embroidered Eyes Baby Small 8" Plush Brown Red $11.00

NEW Schylling Purple Sock Monkey Embroidered Eyes Baby Small 8" Plush Brown Red

0 bids

 2-Rear Russ Berrie Vintage Christmas Mouse Monty 5" Gray Plush Stuffed Animal $6.90

2-Rear Russ Berrie Vintage Christmas Mouse Monty 5" Gray Plush Stuffed Animal

0 bids

Little Buddy 1721 Fire Emblem All Star 10" Lucina Plush,Multicolor $24.99

Little Buddy 1721 Fire Emblem All Star 10" Lucina Plush,Multicolor

0 bids

NEW Kellytoy Squishmallow 7” Astro Chick Peep Easter 2021 Fast Shipping!! $30.00

NEW Kellytoy Squishmallow 7” Astro Chick Peep Easter 2021 Fast Shipping!!

0 bids

Valentina Squishmallow Gray Bunny Easter 2021 Target Exclusive Flattie 15” NEW $32.99

Valentina Squishmallow Gray Bunny Easter 2021 Target Exclusive Flattie 15” NEW

0 bids

Squishmallow Hug Mees 14” Easter 2021 Desirae the Green Dragon by Kelly Toys $36.99

Squishmallow Hug Mees 14” Easter 2021 Desirae the Green Dragon by Kelly Toys

0 bids

Baby Gund Australia Koala Toothpick Baby Plush Toy $25.00

Baby Gund Australia Koala Toothpick Baby Plush Toy

0 bids

Kohls Cares Plush Charlie Brown 14" Peanuts Toy Snoopy Stuffed Animal NWT $5.00

Kohls Cares Plush Charlie Brown 14" Peanuts Toy Snoopy Stuffed Animal NWT

0 bids

NEW 7 inch Aqua the Sloth Easter Squishmallow Soft Plush 2021 $20.00

NEW 7 inch Aqua the Sloth Easter Squishmallow Soft Plush 2021

0 bids

GUND Large 20” Soft Brown Bear Plush Doll Toy Holiday Christmas Tartan Plaid Bow $0.99

GUND Large 20” Soft Brown Bear Plush Doll Toy Holiday Christmas Tartan Plaid Bow

0 bids

Vintage Disney Baby Mickey Mouse Touch & Crawl Mattel Plush Toy Tested 1995 $5.99

Vintage Disney Baby Mickey Mouse Touch & Crawl Mattel Plush Toy Tested 1995

0 bids

New crocheted handmade acrylic white horse with green eyes $35.00

New crocheted handmade acrylic white horse with green eyes

0 bids

Squishmallow frog Wendy 16 inch big $45.00

Squishmallow frog Wendy 16 inch big

0 bids

Realistic Border Collie Dog Handmade Simulation Toy Cute Dog Puppy Kid US $35.79

Realistic Border Collie Dog Handmade Simulation Toy Cute Dog Puppy Kid US

0 bids

Squishmallow Caroleena The Easter Carrot 20” NWT $59.99

Squishmallow Caroleena The Easter Carrot 20” NWT

0 bids

NEW 7” “Aimee the Chick” Squishmallow Plush!  2021 Easter Edition! 🐥 $20.00

NEW 7” “Aimee the Chick” Squishmallow Plush! 2021 Easter Edition! 🐥

0 bids

Blue 13” Dolphin Plush Doll Educational Toy Glitter Eye NWT Under The Sea Gift $0.99

Blue 13” Dolphin Plush Doll Educational Toy Glitter Eye NWT Under The Sea Gift

0 bids

Baby Gap Plush Brannan Teddy Bear in jacket 14" Stuffed Animal nos with tags $7.99

Baby Gap Plush Brannan Teddy Bear in jacket 14" Stuffed Animal nos with tags

0 bids

BRAND NEW 15" LARGE LJ Squishmallow Purple Blue Bunny Easter 2021 Target RARE $45.00

BRAND NEW 15" LARGE LJ Squishmallow Purple Blue Bunny Easter 2021 Target RARE

0 bids

14” RITO the Brown Easter BUNNY Rabbit Squishmallow Hug Mees Plush Toy 2021 $28.95

14” RITO the Brown Easter BUNNY Rabbit Squishmallow Hug Mees Plush Toy 2021

0 bids

NEW “Sophie the Lamb” Kellytoy Squishmallows Plush! 2021 Easter Edition! 8" & 5" $37.99

NEW “Sophie the Lamb” Kellytoy Squishmallows Plush! 2021 Easter Edition! 8" & 5"

0 bids

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Green Octopus Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW $14.99

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Green Octopus Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW

0 bids

First & Main Tender Teddy Brown Bear  12" Plush Stuffed Animal $5.31

First & Main Tender Teddy Brown Bear 12" Plush Stuffed Animal

0 bids

DEMDACO Small Maltipoo Dog Curly Light Brown White Children's Plush Stuffed Toy $34.01

DEMDACO Small Maltipoo Dog Curly Light Brown White Children's Plush Stuffed Toy

0 bids

Bath & Body Works Gingerbread Bear  12" Plush Stuffed Animal with tag $6.29

Bath & Body Works Gingerbread Bear 12" Plush Stuffed Animal with tag

0 bids

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Blue Octopus Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW $14.99

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Blue Octopus Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW

0 bids

Webkinz Ganz BULLDOG Plush Brown Dog Stuffed Animal 9" Pet $12.99

Webkinz Ganz BULLDOG Plush Brown Dog Stuffed Animal 9" Pet

0 bids

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Pink Octopus Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW $14.99

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Pink Octopus Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW

0 bids

NWT Kellytoy Squishmallow The Child Baby Yoda Grogu 10" Plush Stuffed Animal $46.00

NWT Kellytoy Squishmallow The Child Baby Yoda Grogu 10" Plush Stuffed Animal

0 bids

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Red Fox Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW $14.99

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Red Fox Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW

0 bids

Gund fround hog Kohls Cares for Kids Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 12" nos with tag $5.99

Gund fround hog Kohls Cares for Kids Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 12" nos with tag

0 bids

Aurora  7" Peek-A-Boo Purple Llama Plush In Pet Carrier Bag NWT Small Takealong $9.99

Aurora 7" Peek-A-Boo Purple Llama Plush In Pet Carrier Bag NWT Small Takealong

0 bids

Vintage 1977 Wallace & Berrie PENQUIN Plush Mini Stuffed Animal #614 $7.00

Vintage 1977 Wallace & Berrie PENQUIN Plush Mini Stuffed Animal #614

0 bids

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Bald Eagle bird Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW $14.99

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Bald Eagle bird Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW

0 bids

Kelly Toy 30inch Multicolor Caterpillar Plushie $45.00

Kelly Toy 30inch Multicolor Caterpillar Plushie

0 bids

Pokemon Pancham TOMY Plush XY Era 2014 Panda Bear Stuffed Animal $21.99

Pokemon Pancham TOMY Plush XY Era 2014 Panda Bear Stuffed Animal

0 bids

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Penguin bird Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW $14.99

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Penguin bird Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW

0 bids

NEW Kellytoy Squishmallow 7" Aimee The Yellow Chick - Easter Exclusive 2021 $21.99

NEW Kellytoy Squishmallow 7" Aimee The Yellow Chick - Easter Exclusive 2021

0 bids

7" Plush 2017 Peter Rabbit with Blue Coat -  Beatrice Potter - New $3.99

7" Plush 2017 Peter Rabbit with Blue Coat - Beatrice Potter - New

0 bids

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Giraffe Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW $14.99

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Giraffe Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW

0 bids

Cuddle And Kind Chloe The Bunny Large Doll 20” Easter Gift, sold out online $49.00

Cuddle And Kind Chloe The Bunny Large Doll 20” Easter Gift, sold out online

0 bids

🍊 Squishmallow 12" Dakota Pink Dragon Squishmallows plush toy exclusive EUC E9 $249.99

🍊 Squishmallow 12" Dakota Pink Dragon Squishmallows plush toy exclusive EUC E9

0 bids

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Polar Bear Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW $14.99

Wild Republic Itsy Bitsies Polar Bear Plush 3” Stuffed Animal NEW

0 bids

Baby GUND Animated Flappy The Elephant Stuffed Animal Plush, Gray, 12" $47.99

Baby GUND Animated Flappy The Elephant Stuffed Animal Plush, Gray, 12"

0 bids

  • « Previous
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • ...
  • 100
  • Next »
Australia Canada Deutschland France Italia United Kingdom United States